Maloney Real Estate
Illustration of a gray ranch home with white trim, trimmed shrubs and a front walk, with a blank white sale sign post on the lawn under an overcast sky
← The Maloney Report

Seller Guides

Selling a Yankton Rental? How a 1031 Exchange Works

By Michelle Maloney, Broker/Owner, Maloney Real Estate · SD License #14315

If you're selling a Yankton rental house and buying other investment real estate, a 1031 like-kind exchange can let you defer federal tax on the gain instead of recognizing it on this sale. You'll have 45 days after you transfer the rental to identify replacement property in writing, and until the 180th day or your tax return due date, including extensions, whichever is earlier, to receive it. The trade-off is control of the cash, so talk with your tax professional about a qualified intermediary before your sale closes.

Selling a Yankton home? See how Michelle can help you sell your house in Yankton, SD, or find out what your Yankton home is worth.

What is a 1031 exchange, and can your Yankton rental qualify?

It’s a federal tax rule that lets you trade investment real estate for other investment real estate and defer the gain. It can work for a rental. It doesn’t work for a house you use only as your home.

IRS Publication 544 says that if you exchange real property you hold for use in a business or for investment solely for other like-kind real property held the same way, you generally don’t recognize gain or loss on the exchange. The Form 8824 instructions say that since 2018 the rule applies only to real property held for business or investment use, not to real property held primarily for sale.

Both sides have to qualify. Publication 544 says the real property you give up and the real property you receive must both be held for investment or business use. It also says the rules don’t apply to real property used for personal purposes, such as your home. The Form 8824 instructions say section 1031 doesn’t apply if the property you gave up was used solely as your personal residence at the time of the exchange.

Deferred doesn’t mean forgiven. Publication 544 and the federal tax code both say the basis of the property you receive in a like-kind exchange is generally the same as the basis of the property you gave up, with adjustments for money and gain. In plain terms, the gain follows you to the next property.

If you lived in the house at some point and rented it later, tell your tax professional that up front. The Form 8824 instructions have a separate section on property used as a home, so your history with the house matters. Whether your specific property qualifies is a question for your tax professional.

Why does getting the sale money first put the exchange at risk?

Because receiving the money before you have the replacement property can turn the exchange into a sale.

Publication 544 and the federal regulation on deferred exchanges both say that if you actually or constructively receive money for the full amount of the consideration before you receive the replacement property, the transaction is a sale and not a deferred exchange, even if you buy the replacement later. The regulation also says gain or loss may be recognized if you receive money or other property before the replacement, so receiving part of the money early raises its own tax questions.

That’s what a qualified intermediary is for. Publication 544 lists qualified intermediaries among the safe harbors against actual and constructive receipt in a deferred exchange, and the Form 8824 instructions say the qualified intermediary exchange is one safe harbor. The Form 8824 instructions also say that if you make a deferred exchange using a qualified intermediary, the transfer of the property you give up and the receipt of the replacement are treated as a like-kind exchange.

So the timing matters for your Yankton sale. Talk with your tax professional about setting up an intermediary while the sale is still pending, and tell your title company and your agent that the sale is part of an exchange. Ask them how the proceeds will be handled at closing, and get that answer before the closing date.

Pick the intermediary carefully, because it handles the money between your sale and your purchase. Publication 544 and the Form 8824 instructions both describe special rules for when an intermediary defaults or causes you to miss the deadlines, and both say gain may become taxable in that case. Ask your tax professional and attorney how the intermediary holds the funds and what the exchange agreement says.

What are the 45 day and 180 day deadlines?

They’re two clocks, and both start on the date you transfer the property you’re giving up.

The 45 day identification period

Publication 544 says you must identify the replacement property within 45 days after you transfer the property you give up. Both Publication 544 and the Form 8824 instructions say the identification has to be in a signed written document that clearly describes the property, for example by its legal description or street address. Both also say the document can go to the person obligated to transfer the replacement property to you or to another person involved in the exchange who isn’t a disqualified person, and the Form 8824 instructions add that a written agreement signed by all parties to the exchange can designate the replacement instead.

Forty-five days goes fast if you haven’t started looking. If you plan to buy another rental in Yankton, Vermillion or out on acreage, start that search while your sale is still pending.

The 180 day exchange period

Publication 544 and the Form 8824 instructions both say the replacement property has to be received by the earlier of the 180th day after you transfer the property you gave up, or the due date, including extensions, of your tax return for the year of that transfer.

Put both dates on the calendar the day your sale closes. Count them out yourself, then ask your tax professional and the intermediary to confirm them in writing. If the 45th or 180th day lands on a weekend or holiday, ask how they want you to treat it rather than assuming you get an extra day.

Watch the second part of that rule if you sell late in the year. Your return’s due date can come before day 180, so ask your tax professional whether you need an extension to keep the full window.

How does a 1031 change your Yankton sale plan?

It changes the order of your steps and how you plan your time.

A regular sale is simpler. You list, close, take the proceeds and deal with the tax on your return. An exchange adds a purchase to the same calendar. So the decision in front of you is whether you want to keep owning investment real estate enough to run a sale and a purchase on federal deadlines.

Here’s how the sale side changes with an exchange:

  1. Talk to your tax professional before you list, and bring your purchase records, improvement costs and depreciation history for the house.
  2. Line up a qualified intermediary while the sale is pending, with your tax professional’s help.
  3. Tell your title company and your agent that the sale is part of an exchange, and ask how the proceeds will be handled.
  4. Have replacement properties in mind before closing, since the 45 days start when you transfer the rental.
  5. Keep every closing statement and the exchange agreement together, and give copies to your tax professional.

Be honest with yourself about the purchase side. Would you want the next property even without the tax deferral? If the right replacement isn’t out there in your price range, a deadline can push you toward a property you wouldn’t otherwise buy. Selling outright, paying the tax and keeping your options open is also a fair choice. Make it with your tax professional before the calendar makes it for you.

Timing your listing can help. If you know you want to exchange, it may make sense to start touring possible replacement properties before your rental goes on the market, so you aren’t starting from zero on closing day. Your tenant’s lease and move-out date belong on the same calendar.

Cash matters too. Publication 544 says that if you receive money or non-like-kind property as part of the exchange, you recognize gain up to the value of what you received, and the Form 8824 instructions have you report any recognized gain when you receive cash or other non-like-kind property. So if you plan to keep some of the proceeds, expect part of the gain to be taxed and ask your tax professional to run the numbers before you decide how much to reinvest.

If you’re still deciding whether to sell at all, our Yankton home sale net proceeds guide and the seller net sheet help you see what a sale leaves you with. For the broader tax picture on a home you live in, read our post on capital gains on South Dakota home sales, then take your questions to your tax professional before you sign a listing.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can my real estate agent act as the intermediary?

Generally no. Publication 544 and the Form 8824 instructions both count your agent as a disqualified person, and Publication 544 says a qualified intermediary can't be a disqualified person. Publication 544 also explains which past roles count as acting as your agent, so check with your tax professional before you choose.

Can the replacement property be outside the United States?

No, not as like-kind property for your Yankton rental. Publication 544 and the Form 8824 instructions both say real property in the United States and real property outside the United States aren't like-kind.

What if I buy the replacement from a relative?

Special rules apply. Publication 544 and the Form 8824 instructions both say that if you or the related person disposes of the property within 2 years after the exchange, the deferred gain generally has to be reported, and both warn that using an intermediary to buy a relative's property can fail if the relative receives cash. Raise it with your tax professional before you sign anything.

Do I still report the exchange if I owe no tax?

Yes. Publication 544 says you report a like-kind exchange on Form 8824 even when no gain or loss is recognized, and the Form 8824 instructions say you file it with your return for the year you transferred property in a like-kind exchange.

Michelle Maloney

About the Author

Michelle Maloney is the Broker/Owner of Maloney Real Estate in Yankton, South Dakota. She helps buyers and sellers understand the local market, compare their options, and make confident real estate decisions across Yankton and southeast South Dakota.

Listings load as you scroll. Search all listings.

Questions About the Yankton Market?

Ask Michelle's team about pricing, neighborhoods, timing, or your next move. No pitch, no pressure.