Maloney Real Estate
Illustration of a two-story house with a covered front porch, large shade trees, a stone path across the lawn and a wood fence
← The Maloney Report

Buyer Guides

Buying in Yankton? Ask the Seller for the Claims Report

By Michelle Maloney, Broker/Owner, Maloney Real Estate · SD License #14315

If you're under contract on a Yankton home, ask the seller for the property's insurance claims history report, such as a LexisNexis C.L.U.E. report, early in your inspection and insurance window. You can't order it yourself, because these reports are available only to the property's owner, insurer or lender. The seller can get one free every 12 months, and it lists past claims with the date, type and amount paid. It won't show every loss, so take it to your insurance agent and your inspector before your deadlines.

What is a home insurance claims history report?

It’s a consumer report that shows the insurance claims tied to a home. Insurers buy that history to help decide whether to cover a property and what to charge.

One is LexisNexis C.L.U.E., short for Comprehensive Loss Underwriting Exchange. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau calls it a claims information exchange that collects and reports seven years of home insurance and personal property claims to help inform pricing and underwriting decisions. State insurance regulators in Connecticut, Wisconsin and Washington describe the same database as holding up to seven years of personal property claims.

For a home, the report lists:

  • policy information
  • the date of each loss
  • the type of loss
  • the amount paid
  • a description or address of the property covered

Utah’s and Connecticut’s insurance departments both list those items, and Washington’s regulator lists the date of loss, the amount paid and the property address for homeowner claims.

The CFPB’s list of consumer reporting companies says property insurers buy your claims and loss history data from these companies and use it to determine insurance eligibility and rates. The Texas Department of Insurance says insurers use a property’s past claims as a factor in deciding how much you’ll pay for homeowners insurance. So the history you’re about to inherit with the house is history your insurer may already be reading.

That’s why the report belongs in your contract window, while you can still act on it. Utah’s and Connecticut’s insurance departments both say these reports are used almost exclusively to underwrite and rate new policies, which is exactly the quote you’ll be asking for as a buyer. Seeing the history early turns a surprise at quote time into a question you can ask while you still have options.

These reports are covered by federal law, so the request and dispute rights below apply to a Yankton home too. The state guides quoted here come from other states’ insurance regulators. For how a South Dakota insurer uses the report, ask your insurance agent or the South Dakota Division of Insurance.

Why do you have to ask the seller for the claims report?

Because you can’t order it yourself on a home you don’t own yet.

Utah’s insurance department says C.L.U.E. reports can be accessed only by the owner, insurer or lender for the property, and that you can ask the current owner to order one. Connecticut’s department and Wisconsin’s guide say the same. Washington’s regulator puts it plainly: if you need a report on a property you’d like to buy, the owner must request it.

So treat it as a request, and ask early. A seller can say no, and you want to know that while you still have time to work around it.

Put the ask in writing through your real estate agent. Name the property address, ask for the full report rather than a summary, and ask the seller to share it as soon as it arrives. Make sure the report you get lists this property’s address, so you know you’re reading the history of the house you’re buying.

If the seller agrees, ask for a full copy of the report itself. It includes the seller’s personal details, such as name, date of birth and policy number, so it’s fair for the seller to black those out. You’re looking for the dates, types and amounts of losses, so a full copy is more useful than a seller’s summary. Keep it with your inspection report and the seller’s disclosure, because you’ll read all three together.

If the seller says no, make a note of it and lean harder on the other two documents. Your inspector and your insurance agent can still tell you a lot about the roof, the plumbing and the price of coverage.

How does the seller get the report, and how fast?

By request, at no cost once a year, and the company has a deadline to send it.

Federal law makes nationwide specialty consumer reporting companies, including ones that compile files on insurance claims, provide a consumer’s file once every 12 months on request at no charge. The CFPB’s entry for C.L.U.E. says the company will provide one free report every 12 months if requested. Federal law also says the company has to provide it within 15 days after the request is received, and the CFPB’s entry gives the same 15 days.

The request itself is meant to be simple. A federal rule requires each nationwide specialty consumer reporting company to have a streamlined process for these requests, including a toll-free phone number, and the CFPB’s blog on specialty reports says these companies have to provide, at a minimum, a toll-free number to call and order your report.

Do the math on your contract. If your inspection or insurance deadline is a couple of weeks out, a report that takes up to 15 days can land after it. Ask the seller to request it the day you’re under contract, and ask your real estate agent whether your deadlines leave enough room.

What won’t the report tell you?

It shows what insurers reported, which is only part of what happened to the house.

A few gaps to keep in mind:

  • Not every insurer reports. Utah’s and Connecticut’s insurance departments both say losses filed with companies that don’t participate in C.L.U.E. won’t appear on the report. Wisconsin’s guide says the same.
  • A claim can show up without a payment. Connecticut’s department says a claim the insurer didn’t pay can still be recorded and may appear. Utah’s says that calling your company to discuss an actual loss might be considered reporting a claim, even if no payment is made.
  • It’s a loss history, not a repair history. Utah’s insurance department says only loss history information is stored in the database, and Connecticut’s and Wisconsin’s guides say only policy information, including loss history, is stored. For repairs, ask the seller for records separately.

That’s where your inspection does the work the report can’t. Read the report next to the seller’s disclosure and your inspector’s findings, and look for places where the three don’t line up.

A claim with no payment on it still tells you what kind of trouble the house has seen, and that’s worth a question to the seller about what happened and what was done.

What should you do with the claims report before your deadline?

Use it. A claims report only helps if it changes your next call.

The report doesn’t decide anything on its own. It’s one more piece of information to put in front of the people who price and inspect the house, before your deadlines turn into commitments.

Here’s the order that works:

  1. Ask for the report the day you’re under contract. Give the seller the address and a date you need it by.
  2. Send it to your insurance agent first. Ask for a quote on this address with the report in hand, and ask how each past claim affects coverage and price. If a past claim was hail on the roof, ask how the insurer would treat the roof now.
  3. Ask the seller for repair records for each claim. Invoices, the contractor’s name and dates tell you what the report can’t.
  4. Point your inspector at the claim areas. A roof claim, a water loss or a basement claim tells your inspector where to look harder.
  5. If something on the report looks wrong, ask the seller to dispute it. Federal law requires the company to reinvestigate free of charge, generally within 30 days, and Washington’s regulator says the company verifies with the insurer and notifies the consumer within 30 days.
  6. Make your decision while your deadline is still open. If the answers change your insurance cost or your read on the house, talk with your real estate agent about your options while your contract still gives you room.

If you have a problem with an insurance company on a South Dakota policy, start with your insurance agent. The South Dakota Division of Insurance also takes insurance complaints, and its consumer guide says you can file one electronically on its website.

For more on the checks that pair with this one, read our posts on roof age questions for Yankton buyers, what to expect from a South Dakota home inspection and how a seller’s hail repair claim plays out. When you’re ready for the next step in the process, the Yankton buyer guide walks through what comes after inspection.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is LexisNexis the only company with these reports?

No. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau's list of consumer reporting companies also includes A-PLUS Property by Verisk, which it says collects and reports insurance claims and loss history associated with homes, autos or personal property. The CFPB's list says both companies provide one free report every 12 months on request. Ask your insurance agent which one the company quoting you uses.

Can an insurer hold a prior owner's claims against me?

Some state regulators say it can happen. Utah's and Connecticut's insurance departments both say a company may use a prior owner's loss if it can show a relationship to the probability of a future loss, and Wisconsin's guide says a company isn't prohibited from using it if it can show that correlation. Those are other states' guides, so ask the South Dakota Division of Insurance or your insurance agent how it works for a policy here.

Will my insurer pull this report again when the policy renews?

Usually not, according to other states' regulators. Utah's and Connecticut's insurance departments both say C.L.U.E. reports are used almost exclusively to underwrite and rate new policies, and that most insurers renewing existing policies don't access them at renewal. Wisconsin's guide says the same. Ask your insurance agent how the company you choose handles it for a South Dakota policy.

Can the seller add an explanation to a claim on the report?

Yes. Connecticut's insurance department says a consumer can submit a personal statement that LexisNexis adds to all future C.L.U.E. reports, and Washington's regulator says an explanation added to an item will show in all future reports. If a past claim has a story behind it, ask the seller whether they've added one.

Michelle Maloney

About the Author

Michelle Maloney is the Broker/Owner of Maloney Real Estate in Yankton, South Dakota. She helps buyers and sellers understand the local market, compare their options, and make confident real estate decisions across Yankton and southeast South Dakota.

Listings load as you scroll. Search all listings.

Questions About the Yankton Market?

Ask Michelle's team about pricing, neighborhoods, timing, or your next move. No pitch, no pressure.