Maloney Real Estate
Illustration of a single-story house with a gray roof behind a wide lawn and tall shade trees, with a stone path, hostas and white hydrangeas
← The Maloney Report

Buyer Guides

Older Yankton Home Once Heated With Oil? Ask About the Tank

By Michelle Maloney, Broker/Owner, Maloney Real Estate · SD License #14315

If you're buying an older Yankton home that may have been heated with oil, ask the seller about any buried or basement fuel tank before your inspection deadline. South Dakota and federal tank rules both exclude a heating oil tank used on the property where the oil is stored, but a spill from it is still covered by South Dakota's spill reporting rules, and local codes may apply. Your choice is whether the answers and records are enough, or whether you want more checking before you commit.

How do state and federal tank rules treat a home heating oil tank?

They mostly leave it out, so start here.

South Dakota’s Department of Agriculture and Natural Resources (DANR) says tanks used to store heating oil for consumptive use on the premises where it is stored are excluded from the state’s storage tank regulations. DANR’s tank FAQ says the same thing about its underground and aboveground tank rules.

The federal rules line up. EPA’s underground storage tank FAQ says tanks storing heating oil used on the premises where it is stored do not have to meet federal UST regulations, and the definitions in 40 CFR 280.12 exclude a tank used for storing heating oil for consumptive use on the premises where stored.

“Premises” reaches farther than the house. EPA’s FAQ and DANR’s tank FAQ both say the premises is not limited to the building where the heating oil is stored and includes anywhere on the same property, so a central heating unit serving more than one building on the same property still falls under the heating oil exclusion. On a Yankton County acreage with a shop or a second building, that matters.

A basement tank has its own line in the federal rules. The same federal definitions exclude a storage tank in an underground area such as a basement or cellar if it sits on or above the surface of the floor, and EPA’s FAQ lists tanks on or above the floor of underground areas, such as basements, among the tanks that do not have to meet the federal rules.

For you as a buyer, a home heating oil tank falls outside those state and federal tank rules, so plan to get your answers about it from the seller, the records and your own inspection.

What does South Dakota say about oil that leaked from the tank?

A leak is a different story from the tank itself. DANR’s heating oil page says contamination related to a heating oil tank is regulated under spill reporting and should be reported to DANR right away.

Size is one of the triggers. DANR’s heating oil page says any spill over 25 gallons is reportable. South Dakota’s administrative rule on known discharges, ARSD 74:34:01:04, says a responsible person must report a known discharge to the department immediately if, among other conditions, it exceeds 25 gallons or causes a sheen on surface water. DANR’s spill reporting page lists the same 25 gallon and sheen triggers, among other conditions.

Both sources point to the phone. The rule says the immediate report must be telephoned to the department, and DANR’s spill reporting page says to call DANR to report a release or spill. DANR’s heating oil page and its spill reporting page both list 605.773.3296 for DANR’s program.

Who counts as the “responsible person” is a question for DANR or an attorney, not for you to settle from a listing. As a buyer, start by asking whether anyone has ever found oil in the soil, in the basement or around an old fill pipe, and what was done about it. If the answer is yes, ask for the paperwork, and ask your attorney what it means for your purchase.

What should you ask the seller before your inspection deadline?

Ask early, and ask in writing. Start with these four questions:

  1. Was the home ever heated with oil? If the seller doesn’t know, ask whether there are records from when the heating system was changed.
  2. Is there a tank now, and where? Buried in the yard, in the basement, or removed. A basement tank on or above the floor is treated differently under the federal definitions than a buried one.
  3. If a tank was removed or emptied, who did it and when? Ask for invoices or any written report.
  4. Has anyone ever reported a spill to DANR? If yes, ask for the report and any letters back from DANR.

The seller disclosure helps you start this conversation. South Dakota’s property condition disclosure statement, set out in SDCL 43-4-44 and posted as a form on the state’s real estate licensing site, has a hazardous conditions section that lists “Buried Fuel Tanks” and “Chemical Storage Tanks,” with columns for whether the seller is aware of an existing condition and whether any tests were performed. Read those two lines, and the comments, before you rely on anything else.

One more line on the form is worth a look. In its structural information section, the disclosure asks whether the seller is aware of any drainage, leakage or runoff from any sewer, septic tank, storage tank or drain on the property into any adjoining lake, stream or waterway. On a property near the Missouri River or a creek, read that answer next to the two tank lines.

The form also says that if any material fact changes before closing, the seller must disclose the change in a written amendment to the disclosure statement and give it to the buyer. If your questions turn up something new, watch for that amendment.

Then talk with your inspector about what they will and won’t look at. Ask whether they note old fill pipes, vent pipes or abandoned oil lines, whether they look at a basement tank if one is there, and what they recommend if they find signs of one. If they don’t cover it, ask who does, and get that name before your deadline rather than after. Our post on what to expect from a South Dakota home inspection covers how to set up that conversation, and if the house has an older heating system, boiler heat in an older Yankton home walks through the questions for that system.

Do Yankton or local codes add anything for an old tank?

They might, and you find out by asking. DANR’s heating oil page says there may be local codes or requirements that apply to heating oil tanks and tells people to check with their local city or fire official. EPA’s FAQ says state or local regulatory agencies may regulate heating oil tanks even though the federal rules exclude them.

For a home in town, that means a call to the City of Yankton about any local rule on old fuel tanks. For a rural property, ask Yankton County and the local fire district who handles it. Write down who you talked to and what they said. If anyone tells you a rule applies, ask for it in writing or ask where it is published, so you and your agent are working from the same page when you decide what to ask the seller for.

What do you weigh before you remove your contingency?

This is a judgment call, and it’s yours. Line up what you know.

What you found What it suggests next
No sign of oil heat and the seller says never Read the disclosure lines and keep it on your normal inspection list
An empty basement tank with cleaning or service records Ask your inspector to look at it and decide whether you want it removed before closing
A buried tank or fill pipe, no records Ask what it would take to find out more before your deadline, and get answers in writing
Any report of a past spill Get the DANR paperwork and ask your attorney what it means for you

Keep your notes in one place as you go: what the seller said, what the disclosure shows on the two tank lines, what the inspector found, and who you talked to at the city, the county or DANR. When it’s time to decide, you’ll be reading your own record instead of trying to remember who said what.

If you want more time, more information or a different deal, talk with your agent before the deadline in your purchase agreement passes, not after. Our after accepting an offer guide lays out how those deadlines usually run, and the buyer guide covers the steps from search to closing.

Before your inspection deadline, put the four seller questions in writing, read the two tank lines on the disclosure, and make your call with the answers in hand.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does kerosene or diesel count as heating oil?

The two agencies word it differently. DANR's tank FAQ lists No. 2 diesel fuel and kerosene within heating oil when used for heating purposes, and EPA's FAQ says they are not defined as heating oil but are considered a substitute for it when used for heating purposes only. Ask DANR how your fuel is treated if it matters to your purchase.

Does the disclosure form ask about propane tanks too?

Yes, in a different place. The property condition disclosure in SDCL 43-4-44 and the Real Estate Commission's copy of the form both have a propane tank line that asks whether the tank is leased or owned. The buried fuel tank question sits in the separate hazardous conditions section.

Does a spill under 25 gallons still need a report?

It can. ARSD 74:34:01:04 and DANR's spill reporting page both list other conditions that call for an immediate report, including a discharge that threatens the waters of the state or causes an immediate danger to human health or safety. Ask DANR about any spill you learn of, whatever its size.

Is the seller's disclosure a warranty that there is no tank?

No. SDCL 43-4-44 and the South Dakota Real Estate Commission's copy of the disclosure form both say the statement is not a warranty of any kind and not a substitute for any inspections or warranties either party may want.

Michelle Maloney

About the Author

Michelle Maloney is the Broker/Owner of Maloney Real Estate in Yankton, South Dakota. She helps buyers and sellers understand the local market, compare their options, and make confident real estate decisions across Yankton and southeast South Dakota.

Listings load as you scroll. Search all listings.

Questions About the Yankton Market?

Ask Michelle's team about pricing, neighborhoods, timing, or your next move. No pitch, no pressure.